Colnaghi Foundation Journal 03 - Page 15
13
For Jennifer Fletcher
A Renaissance Madonna and Child with the
Infant Saint John the Baptist in Kirkcaldy
JOH N GASH
An attractive painting of the Madonna and Child with the
Infant Saint John the Baptist on a medium-sized, poplarwood panel (82.5 x 64.3 cm) has long preserved its secrets
away from the public gaze in the reserve collection of
the Kirkcaldy Museum and Art Gallery, Fife (fig. 1).1
It was transferred there from Anstruther Town Hall
between 1975 and 1984, and nothing earlier is known
about its provenance.2 However, an old strip of paper
on the back bears the name of the great Florentine
High Renaissance master, Andrea del Sarto (14861530), once viewed by the likes of Robert Browning
and Heinrich Wölfflin as the epitome of a Renaissance
artist. The picture is in reasonable condition, though
there is evidence of woodworm on the back of the panel
and there are scattered small paint losses on the front,
some of which have been filled in. Its rainbow palette
has been somewhat dimmed by discoloured varnish and
would benefit from a full conservation, which is currently
envisaged. Such an intervention might even further
elevate the picture’s quality.
Fig.1 / Circle of Domenico
Puligo, Madonna and Child
with the Infant Saint John
the Baptist, 1520s-1530s,
oil on panel, 82.5 x 64.3 cm,
Kirkcaldy (Fife), Museum
and Art Gallery.
The broad similarity with Andrea’s style is indisputable,
not least in its colouring, composition, and landscape
(figs. 2 and 3), and explains the old attribution.
However, neither the handling nor the characterization
betray Andrea’s immaculate finish, nor the deeply
engaged cast of thought of his figures. Indeed the
facial types are quite unlike Andrea’s. We are dealing,
rather, with a skilful work by one of his many pupils or
imitators, with an emphasis on prettiness (the Virgin’s
Hollywood face) and elegance (the Christ Child’s
Mohican quiff). It opens up the complex and underresearched area of Andrea’s studio and influence.3
Vasari refers to the many pupils who passed through
his workshop for varying lengths of time, sometimes
driven away by their lack of rapport with Andrea’s
allegedly domineering wife, Lucrezia del Fede, while
he also mentions other artists as close friends or
associates who worked alongside him. One of the latter
was Domenico Puligo (1492-1527) who, according to
Vasari, spent almost all his time painting Madonnas,
and whose works are to this day still sometimes
confused with Andrea’s.4 Andrea, it seems, “was never
so happy as when Domenico was in his workshop
learning from him.”5 Puligo’s facial types, poses, and
compositions bear especially close comparison with
the Kirkcaldy picture (see fig. 4), even if the Fife panel
seems somewhat harder in handling than Puligo’s
soft brushwork, and also rather more Mannerist,
possibly placing it in the 1530s rather than 1520s.
However, the contrapposto pose and splayed legs of
the Kirkcaldy Christ Child, as well as the picture’s
overall composition, are closer to Puligo’s Madonna and
Child with Saint John the Baptist in the Galleria Palatina
of Palazzo Pitti (fig. 4) than they are to Andrea’s
prototypes (see fig. 2). It is, therefore, tempting to view
the Kirkcaldy panel as emanating from Puligo’s circle,
or even studio, rather than that of Andrea, in so far as
they were distinct. Other works either by or attributed
to Puligo are also close in feel to the Kirkcaldy Virgin
and Child with the Infant Saint John. For example, the face
of the Christ Child in a panel attributed to Puligo,
now in Nantes (fig. 5), is very similar to that of the
Kirkcaldy Saviour. Likewise Puligo’s Holy Family with
the Infant Saint John in the Pitti (fig. 6) has several links
with the Kirkcaldy panel, from the now reversed pose
- Page 1
- Page 2
- Page 3
- Page 4
- Page 5
- Page 6
- Page 7
- Page 8
- Page 9
- Page 10
- Page 11
- Page 12
- Page 13
- Page 14
- Page 15
- Page 16
- Page 17
- Page 18
- Page 19
- Page 20
- Page 21
- Page 22
- Page 23
- Page 24
- Page 25
- Page 26
- Page 27
- Page 28
- Page 29
- Page 30
- Page 31
- Page 32
- Page 33
- Page 34
- Page 35
- Page 36
- Page 37
- Page 38
- Page 39
- Page 40
- Page 41
- Page 42
- Page 43
- Page 44
- Page 45
- Page 46
- Page 47
- Page 48
- Page 49
- Page 50
- Page 51
- Page 52
- Page 53
- Page 54
- Page 55
- Page 56
- Page 57
- Page 58
- Page 59
- Page 60
- Page 61
- Page 62
- Page 63
- Page 64
- Page 65
- Page 66
- Page 67
- Page 68
- Page 69
- Page 70
- Page 71
- Page 72
- Page 73
- Page 74
- Page 75
- Page 76
- Page 77
- Page 78
- Page 79
- Page 80
- Page 81
- Page 82
- Page 83
- Page 84
- Page 85
- Page 86
- Page 87
- Page 88
- Page 89
- Page 90
- Page 91
- Page 92
- Page 93
- Page 94
- Page 95
- Page 96
- Page 97
- Page 98
- Page 99
- Page 100
- Page 101
- Page 102
- Page 103
- Page 104
- Page 105
- Page 106
- Page 107
- Page 108
- Page 109
- Page 110
- Page 111
- Page 112
- Page 113
- Page 114
- Page 115
- Page 116
- Page 117
- Page 118
- Page 119
- Page 120
- Page 121
- Page 122
- Page 123
- Page 124
- Page 125
- Page 126
- Page 127
- Page 128
- Page 129
- Page 130
- Page 131
- Page 132
- Page 133
- Page 134
- Page 135
- Page 136
- Page 137
- Page 138
- Page 139
- Page 140
- Page 141
- Page 142
- Page 143
- Page 144
- Page 145
- Page 146
- Page 147
- Page 148
- Page 149
- Page 150
- Page 151
- Page 152
- Page 153
- Page 154
- Page 155
- Page 156
- Page 157
- Page 158
- Page 159
- Page 160
- Page 161
- Page 162
- Page 163
- Page 164
- Page 165
- Page 166
- Page 167
- Page 168
- Page 169
- Page 170
- Page 171
- Page 172
- Page 173
- Page 174
- Page 175
- Page 176
- Page 177
- Page 178
- Page 179
- Page 180
- Page 181
- Page 182
- Page 183
- Page 184
- Page 185
- Page 186
- Page 187
- Page 188
- Page 189
- Page 190
- Page 191
- Page 192
- Page 193
- Page 194
- Page 195
- Page 196
- Page 197
- Page 198
- Page 199
- Page 200
- Page 201
- Page 202
- Page 203
- Page 204
- Page 205
- Page 206
- Page 207
- Page 208

Powered by
